Are you searching for amazing restaurants in Key Largo, FL? Look no further! Key Largo, the first of the Florida Keys, offers a diverse culinary scene that's sure to tantalize your taste buds. From fresh seafood shacks to upscale dining experiences, there's something for everyone. Let's dive into some of the best spots to grab a bite in this tropical paradise.

Exploring the Culinary Scene of Key Largo

Key Largo's restaurant scene is as vibrant and colorful as its coral reefs. You'll find a delightful mix of cuisines, reflecting the island's laid-back atmosphere and rich cultural influences. Seafood is, of course, a major draw, with many restaurants serving up the freshest catches of the day. But don't think that's all there is! You'll also discover Italian eateries, Cuban cafes, and American grills, each adding its unique flavor to the local food landscape.

When choosing a restaurant, consider what kind of experience you're after. Want a casual meal with your toes in the sand? Several beachfront spots offer exactly that. Looking for a romantic dinner with stunning sunset views? You'll find plenty of options. Or perhaps you're in the mood for some live music and a lively atmosphere? Key Largo has got you covered. And when you are trying to find the right restaurant for you, remember to check the reviews and the menu, that way you are ready to go!

No matter your preference, you're guaranteed to find delicious food and friendly service in Key Largo. The island's chefs are passionate about their craft, and they take pride in showcasing the best of what the Florida Keys have to offer. So, get ready to embark on a culinary adventure and discover your new favorite restaurant in Key Largo!

Must-Visit Restaurants in Key Largo

Okay, guys, let’s get into the specifics. Here are some top-rated restaurants in Key Largo that you absolutely need to check out:

1. The Fish House

The Fish House is a Key Largo institution, known for its incredibly fresh seafood and lively atmosphere. This place is always buzzing, and for good reason. They serve up some of the best fish sandwiches, seafood platters, and daily specials you'll ever taste. Expect generous portions, friendly service, and a true taste of the Florida Keys.

Why you need to visit: The atmosphere is amazing, located right next to the water! They have a diverse menu that includes local seafood and other American Cuisine. The must try dishes are the sea food platter and the grilled fish sandwich, it is also a great place for families and friends. Expect to spend about 20-40$ per person.

The Fish House is separated into two different experiences: The Fish House and The Fish House Encore. The Fish House offers a family friendly and casual environment, with many great options of locally sourced sea food. The Fish House Encore offers the same great sea food but with a more upscale and romantic environment. No matter which one you choose, they both offer great experiences and are a must visit.

2. Sundowners

If you're dreaming of dining with a view, Sundowners is the place to be. This waterfront restaurant offers breathtaking sunset vistas, delicious food, and a relaxed island vibe. Their menu features a mix of seafood, American classics, and tropical-inspired cocktails. It's the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a casual meal with friends.

Why you need to visit: Imagine sipping on a refreshing cocktail while watching the sun dip below the horizon. They have a wide variety of seafood dishes and other American classics. The atmosphere is romantic and relaxing, perfect for a night out with your significant other. Expect to spend about 30-50$ per person.

This location offers a one of a kind experience, not only because of the amazing sea food, but because of the events and parties they throw, Sundowners also has live music, karaoke nights and other events, making it the perfect place for a great night out. It is highly recommended to try their amazing desserts, which include key lime pie and other amazing sweets.

3. Key Largo Conch House

For a truly unique dining experience, head to the Key Largo Conch House. This charming restaurant is housed in a historic building and serves up creative conch dishes alongside other Caribbean-inspired fare. Their conch fritters are a must-try, and their outdoor patio is a lovely spot to enjoy a meal.

Why you need to visit: Key Largo Conch House is a hidden gem that offers a unique culinary experience. They focus on sustainable seafood and use locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, making it a great spot for a special occasion. Expect to spend about 25-45$ per person.

Located near a beautiful garden, the Key Largo Conch House is an experience unlike any other. With dishes like conch salad, conch chowder, and cracked conch, you're sure to find something new and exciting to try. This is a great location for couples and families, with a warm and welcoming environment.

4. Gus' Grille

Gus' Grille offers the best of both worlds, with excellent dining options for breakfast, lunch and dinner! Located within the Hampton Inn of Key Largo, it is a local's favorite for any meal of the day! The location is also perfect, right on the water.

Why you need to visit: Some stand out options from the menu include, french toast, omelets, burgers, and seafood. They also have many healthy options, and it is also a great option for anyone with dietary restrictions. Expect to spend about 15-30$ per person.

With a laid back atmosphere and live music, it is the perfect location for anyone wanting to have a great time while enjoying some delicious food! Gus' Grille is a great location for families and friends, with an ample menu that can accommodate to most people. A local's favorite, it is the perfect location for anyone wanting to experience Key Largo as a local.

5. Bayside Grill

If you're after a more upscale dining experience, Bayside Grill is an excellent choice. This elegant restaurant offers stunning bay views, a sophisticated atmosphere, and a menu featuring fresh seafood, prime steaks, and creative cocktails. It's the perfect spot for a special occasion or a memorable night out.

Why you need to visit: This location is ideal for a romantic dinner, offering breathtaking views from all areas of the restaurant! You can find quality seafood, fresh oysters, and a wide variety of wines. Bayside Grill is a great location to unwind and enjoy the beautiful Florida Keys with their incredible service and ambiance. Expect to spend about 40-60$ per person.

With friendly staff and high quality ingredients, Bayside Grill will be an unforgettable experience. Located right next to the water, you can sit outside and enjoy the breeze while watching the sunset. While on the higher end, it is the perfect place to celebrate a special occasion with your friends and family!

Tips for Dining in Key Largo

To make the most of your dining experiences in Key Largo, keep these tips in mind:

• Make reservations: Especially during peak season, popular restaurants can get busy. Booking a table in advance will save you time and hassle.
• Check the dress code: While Key Largo is generally casual, some upscale restaurants may have a dress code. It's always a good idea to check beforehand.
• Ask about daily specials: Many restaurants offer daily specials that showcase the freshest catches and seasonal ingredients. Don't be afraid to ask your server for recommendations.
• Embrace the local flavors: Be sure to try some of the local specialties, such as conch fritters, key lime pie, and fresh seafood. You won't be disappointed!
• Enjoy the view: Key Largo is known for its stunning waterfront views. Choose a restaurant that offers outdoor seating and soak in the scenery while you dine.

Final Thoughts

Key Largo is a food lover's paradise, with a diverse array of restaurants to suit every taste and budget. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, classic American fare, or international flavors, you're sure to find something to satisfy your appetite. So, grab your sunscreen, pack your appetite, and get ready to explore the delicious culinary scene of Key Largo!

Have you tried any of these restaurants? What are some of your favorite dining spots in Key Largo? Share your recommendations in the comments below!